Bubble Economy puts second notch on Virginia Gold Cup

Timber classic

By Betsy Burke Parker
Special to the Times-Democrat
With more divergent storylines than a Shakespearean drama, the 2010 Virginia Gold Cup turned out one part Dick Francis mystery, one part My Friend Flicka, with a side order of The Keystone Cops.
Arcadia Stable’s Bubble Economy pulled off a second score in the 85th anniversary running of the timber classic. But from before the start it was a win that nearly wasn’t.
The $75,000 headliner attracted 11 of the division’s elite, including 2008 Gold Cup winner Bubble Economy. The story became compelling Saturday morning when Bubble Economy’s stablemate Seeyouattheevent was a surprise defection a few hours before post time. Morning-line favorite on the strength of a solid April 17 win, Seeyouattheevent was mysteriously scratched, late, by trainer Jack Fisher. Fisher was predictably tight-lipped but allowed that Seeyouattheevent had been injured and would have the balance of the year off.
It was up to the two-time national champ, then, to secure a 11th Gold Cup score for the Maryland-based Fisher. All that stood between Bubble Economy and the historic stake were four grueling miles and 23 sturdy fences. And 10 competitors. At least there were when they left the saddling enclosure.
The plot thickened down at the start when one horse, Meet At Eleven, was kicked by another fractious entrant after the eager field clumped up when recalled from a false start. It was an accident, but one with serious consequences. The course veterinarian was on hand within minutes, quickly determining that while Meet At Eleven was not visibly injured, the direct blow to his lower leg could have lasting effect. The horse was scratched and sent back to the stable, further delaying the start as he left the course.
At last away from the flag, J. Alfred Prufrock and He’s A Conniver were off smoothly to set blistering early fractions, 2009 division champ Patriot’s Path and Fort Henry in their wake. Defending champion rider Paddy Young allowed Bubble Economy to settle into rhythm, finding stride mid-field as the group circled the Great Meadow oval.
“My horse was jumping well” in the early going, Young reported, “but just dawdling along. I kept him back, … covered up early.” Young noted that Bubble Economy, a notorious “thinker” on the racecourse, should not be allowed to get the lead too early in his races, as he was likely to “just up and quit running” if alone on the front. He’s even refused fence when on the lead, a trick he pulled in the ‘08 Pennsylvania Hunt Cup. “So you keep him back,” Young explained of his strategy.
After completing three of the four miles, Fort Henry and He’s A Conniver were outpaced and eased, undone by the torrid pace and hot, humid day.
Young said he was unconcerned when shuffled back in to sixth headed to the pivotal water jump at 19. Nonchalance turned to alarm as Bubble Economy flew the fence, drawing even with the leaders.
“I was thinking, ‘that horse is some kind of bastard’,” said Fisher of his thoughts watching timber racing’s “bad boy” take the lead with three fences, and a half-mile, to go. “You don’t know what he’ll do. He stops. He’ll screw around. He’s like a naughty schoolkid, always getting into trouble when he’s left alone. I was thinking lots of bad words.”
Young, too, worried. “I looked around for who was coming,” he said. Turning left, then right, searching for company, Young locked in on a looming Bon Caddo, lightly regarded but fencing superbly and taking dead aim on the leader from 10 lengths back in second.
“I saw Paddy keep looking back,” said jockey Patrick Worrall, at once confused by Young’s apparent hesitation but buoyed by the response from Bon Caddo. “I thought we had it.”
Bon Caddo advanced steadily to collar Bubble Economy on the long run from the north turn. And when the champ faltered with a casual step over the final jump, he surrendered the lead as Bon Caddo gained a length landing the last. “I set my horse down to the wire,” Worrall said. “But I could hear Bubble Economy coming back to me.”
And the race was on. 
The world-class loafer was, at last, provoked into action. With encouragement – hands and heels only (Young: “he’s not a horse you can use your whip on”) – from his jockey, Bubble Economy sparked up with the challenge and picked up his pace to the wire to win by a half-length.
“I was never so glad to have a long run-in,” Young said.
The winning time, 8:22 4/5, is second-fastest since the Gold Cup moved to Great Meadow near The Plains in 1985.
Owned by the Arcadia Stable syndicate, the winner adds to a steeplechase career that began as a 3-year-old back in 2002. Once part of trainer Rick Violette’s flat stable, the Pennsylvania-bred won for the 12th time over jumps and pushed his career earnings past $388,000 with the $45,000 payday.

In other races Saturday, Young also scored with steeplethon winner The Whacker. Young, riding for owner Robert Kinsley and champion trainer Tom Voss, said the second-season jumper was “a bit surprised” with the variety of fences he found on the unique course that combines timber, brush, a stone wall, open ditch, 100-foot long water splash and more. “But he got into a rhythm as the race progressed,” Young added. At the wire, local favorite Swimming River, owned by Indian Run Farm in Flint Hill, got within a half-length, but The Whacker prevailed for a $12,000 payday.
Indian Run was within a half-length of joining fellow Flint Hill ‘chase owners Julia Thieriot and Charley and Susan Strittmatters’ Clorevia Farm for a unique triple play at Great Meadow. Thieriot’s Fantastic Foe (Carl Rafter) easily handled a tough bunch to win the allowance hurdle, while Clorevia’s Star For Tina (Xavier Aizpuru) won the maiden claimer to close the day. Thieriot and the Strittmatters are next-door neighbors just across the Fauquier-Rappahannock line; Indian Run is just down the road. Perhaps the most “local” winner of all, though was Commodore Bob in the maiden hurdle. Ridden by Willie Dowling, the 6-year-old gutted out the score over Class Century (Carl Rafter) to win for owner Nick Arundel, who created the Great Meadow racecourse in the early 1980s to provide a permanent home for the Virginia Gold Cup, which lost it’s course when Broadview near downtown Warrenton was sold for development.

At Sunday’s rescheduled Blue Ridge Hunt Point-to-Point in Berryville, Ben Garner handled a pair of winners, taking the maiden turf with first-time-starter It’s a School Night for owner Kinross Farm, and the allowance turf with Gregg Ryan’s Three Bridge Road. The English native is based in The Plains.
The local ‘chase schedule takes a week off before resuming action May 15 for the Strawberry Hill Races at Colonial Downs near Richmond. Colonial will host jump races throughout the parimutuel track’s summer “turf festival” meet in June and July.
Complete results are online at http://www.NationalSteeplechase.com or http://www.CentralEntryOffice.com.

It was an all-star lineup Saturday at Glenwood Park, with six of timber racing’s elite lining up for the $20,000 Middleburg Hunt Cup, widely considered a telling tightener for the Virginia Gold Cup timber classic two weeks hence.
The Hunt Cup was run as the co-feauture at the April 17 Middleburg Spring Races just north of town,
Nick Arundel’s Seeyouattheevent made up for his narrow loss in last year’s Hunt Cup to win easily, handing a two-length beating to Rainbows For Luck and Erin Go Bragh. Willi Dowling handled the winner for trainer Jack Fisher. Fisher was pleased with the way the 9-year-old managed the torrid late pace. “He’s good and ready to go in two weeks,” said Maryland-based Fisher of the targeted Gold Cup. Arundel, who lives in The Plains near the Great Meadow course he designed as permanent home for the historic Gold Cup stake. Fisher said he readily recognizes the importance of Seeyouattheevent being primed for the home course. “He’ll be ready,” he said with confidence.
Seeyouattheevent won the International Gold Cup over the same course (at 3 ½ miles) last fall. He also won there in 2007.
Over hurdles, 2008 champion claimer Slip Away handled the 2 1/2-miles in his patent winging style on the front end, handing defeat to a star-studded field of six in the $50,000 Temple Gwathmey hurdle stake, grade 3. The group included last year’s hurdle titlist Mixed Up and early-season headliner Spy In The Sky. Trainer Tom Voss unveiled his gray 7-year-old primed for his ‘10 debut.
Speed, Voss noted, is dangerous, “Especially here,” he said of Glenwood’s extra-long stretch, which stretches out a front-runner like Slip Away. “I didn’t anticipate them sticking to me so early,” said winning jockey Xavier Aizpuru of the persistent Dynantonia, who pressed the pace throughout much of the first two miles. Slip Away finally shook his pursuer last up the backside, drawing off by nearly nine by the wire.
Chess Board was second, with Dyantonia third.
Aizpuru subbed for Voss’ regular rider Ross Geraghty when Geraghty selected an unfortunate week to go home to Ireland to renew his P-1 visa: like thousands of others he was stranded when airline travel was curtailed by the Icelandic volcano.
“I hate it for Ross, but love it for me,” said Aizpuru, 2007 U.S. champ.
Slip Away won the Ferguson last summer at Colonial Downs and ended his campaign with a runaway victory in the Noel Laing at Montpelier Nov. 7.
Some of American ‘chasing’s elite have won the Gwathmey, which has been held at New York’s Belmont Park and Aqueduct and at the old Rolling Rock meet in Pennsylvania in its 86-year-history. Prior winners read like who’s who, including champions Jungle King (1937), The Mast (1952), King Commander (1954), Jeni (1955 and ‘57), Benguala (1960), Peale (1961), Barnaby’s Bluff (1962), Amber Diver (1963), Bon Nouvel (1965), Top Bid (1970), Shadow Brook (1971), Soothsayer (1972), Athenial Idol (1973), Fire Control (1976 and ‘78), Zaccio (1982), Flatterer (1983 and ‘85), Warm Spell (1993) and Lonesome Glory (1994.)
Other Glenwood winners included Kinross Farm’s Poplar Grove (Matt McCarron up) in the maiden hurdle. McCarrron also handled Oakwood Stable’s Country Cousin to win the allowance. Teddy Mulligan saddled Brands Hatch (Jeff Murphy up) to win the Alfred Hunt ‘chase, 2 5/8-miles over varied fences.
The Middleburg card closed with the return of 2009 novice champ Left Unsaid. Trained by Tom Voss for The Fields Stable, Left Unsaid cemented his championship with a dominant win in the Foxbrook last October at Far Hills. Aizpuru was up.
** Sunday’s Fairfax Hunt Point-to-Point provided a peek at two other potential Gold Cup contenders, with timber-bred Excentrikbydesign, Darren Nagle up, winning the 3 1/4-mile Bowman Bowl in textbook, jumping clinic style. The 6-year-old bay was custom-made for a steeplechase career – dam Ursula G was born at longtime steeplechase owner-breeder Sara Collette’s Pageland Farm in Casanova, daughter of Collette’s winning hurdler Melantha, also a homebred. That Melantha is also the dam of Gold Cup winner Salmo was not lost on Excentrikbydesign’s owner Irv Naylor, who owned Salmo when he won the 2007 and ‘09 Virginia Gold Cups.
“He’s just a class act,” trainer Desmond Fogarty said of the leggy gelding. “He’s been a bit slow to mature, come to hand, but I like what he did today.” Fogarty likes Excentrikbydesign’s chances at the Gold Cup’s four miles, though he allowed that since the horse has only started a half-dozen times, and won just once, this year’s Cup could be a push. “We might look at Winterthur” on May 2,” he said.
Longtime Fairfax Hunt master Randy Rouse helped organize the club’s first races, sanctioned by the National Steeplechase Association, in 1958. Sunday he saddled his own One Sea to win the Guest Cup open hurdle feature. The veteran was sired by Sea Hero, Virginia-bred winner of the 1993 Kentucky Derby.
Owner Gordon Keys, trainer Simon Hobson and jockey Jeff Murphy teamed up with a pair of turf winners at the Morven Park meet – homebred Whatadance in the maiden and I’m A Wahoo in the Virginia-bred.
Complete results are online at http://www.NationalSteeplechase.com and http://www.CentralEntryOffice.com.

Arthur Arundel’s SeeYouAtTheEvent won Saturday’s featured Middleburg Hunt Cup at Glenwood Park. Here,the horse races at far right to lead from the last fence into the long Middleburg course’s homestretch.
Considered a key prep for the May 1 Virginia Gold Cup, the elite field included last year’s Hunt Cup winner Erin Go Bragh, center—third here, and Delta Park, unplaced.
Also at Glenwood, former claimer Slip Away won the $50,000 Temple Gwathmey hurdle stakes, grade III for owner Ken Ramsey.