Mobile Website | Login | Register
Staff Directory | Subscribe | About Us
Business Government Politics Region Crime/Public Safety Education People E-edition Ashburn Hamilton Hillsboro Lansdowne Leesburg Lovettsville Middleburg Purcellville River Creek Round Hill Sterling
Basketball Football Youth Wrestling Gymnastics Swimming Volleyball Baseball Track Golf Cheer Cross Country Schedule Scores
Brambleton Community of Faith Hangin in the Nosebleeds Journal Entry Loudoun Essence Made in Loudoun Odd Angles River Creek & Lansdowne South Riding Sterling, Cascades & CountrySide
This Week's Slideshow Browse All Galleries Your Best Dish Featured Video The Virginians
  • Announcements
  • Autos
  • Jobs
  • Legals
  • Homes
  • YardSales
  • Submit an Ad
  • Newspaper Advertising Online Advertising
    Classified listings Homes section
    Opinions
    Editorial | Wednesday, Feb. 25
    EDITORIAL: The perfect flip-flop
    Borrowing an 18th century aphorism from a French philosopher – don’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good – Loudoun County supervisors have made a bad decision about a 21st century problem.

    By approving the latest iteration of the Tuscarora Crossing development, they flipped-flopped their way to justifying policy that can only be characterized as haphazard.

    For a few years now, supervisors have been of one mind: reject residential rezonings that cost more to support than the tax revenue that most residential developments generate. While some suggest the position is closing the barn door after the horse has bolted, supervisors have nonetheless favored commercial developments that pay the bills for an expanding county infrastructure.

    Tuscarora Crossing, 250 acres of strategically situated property between the Village at Leesburg and Kincaid Forest southeast of Leesburg, has tested the resolve of supervisors.

    Since 2012, the project has changed with the winds of growth – from all residential to less residential to mixed-use, roughly half of which is commercial or industrial.

    Developer Hunter Lee never embraced the industrial direction, starting with a residential project of 800 homes. County planners had other ideas. They contended that the county’s Comprehensive Plan calls for primarily business uses and a smattering of houses on the industrially zoned site, which includes a utility plant, sewer plant and quarry.

    Last week the project morphed back to residential with the developer reducing residential units to fewer than 500. As part of a $40 million proffer package, the developers also agreed to extend Crosstrail Boulevard through the property, dedicate 15 acres for a school or other county uses and to contribute $100,000 to two area playgrounds.

    That was enough to flip Shawn Williams, the vice chair of the Board of Supervisors and the swing vote. Williams was joined by Supervisor Gerry Higgins (R-Catoctin), whose district covers the Tuscarora Crossing property, Chairman Scott York (R-At Large), Suzanne Volpe (R-Algonkian) and Janet Clarke (R-Blue Ridge).

    A perfect decision? Depends on whom you ask.

    “At the end of the day, they didn’t let the perfect be the enemy of the amazing,” said an attorney for the developer.

    “While nothing is perfect, it’s a much better application that it started out,” said Higgins.

    But opponents contend the 5-4 decision to turn revenue-positive commercially zoned land to revenue-negative residential development will cost the county millions.

    “I hear my colleagues all the time, all the time – ‘We have to increase the commercial tax base so we can hold the tax rate low,’” Ralph Buona (R-Ashburn) said, “and then some of you [supervisors] are going to turn around and vote for this application.

    Buona said he couldn’t justify converting the best industrial plot of land in the county to a project to build 500 homes.

    That’s just one of our concerns. For decades now, county leaders have flip-flopped over the best ways to stimulate and manage growth. That’s brought problems such as overcrowded schools, congested roads and a tax structure that’s insufficient to meet needed costs and services.

    Loudoun needs a new Comprehensive Plan, a road map for decision-making about growth into the future. Until then, it excuses flip-flop decisions that exacerbate our current problems.

    Submit a Letter
    COMMUNITY VIEW: Protect waters while we can
    Wed., Feb. 25 | 10:00 AM
    What’s in a name? A trademark fight
    Wed., Feb. 25 | 09:45 AM
    Residents willing to pay for quality education
    Wed., Feb. 25 | 09:30 AM
    3 comments
    Politics, indiscretions and the context of a tweet
    Wed., Feb. 25 | 09:00 AM
    The way of water: It flows with tenacity to just resolution
    Wed., Feb. 25 | 08:30 AM
    Middleburg Charter School directors challenge report of teacher exodus
    Wed., Feb. 25 | 08:00 AM
    COMMUNITY VIEW: Human trafficking is problem in NOVA
    Wed., Feb. 18 | 09:45 AM
    2 comments
    COMMUNITY VIEW: Legislation helps utilities, not ratepayers
    Wed., Feb. 18 | 09:30 AM
    1 comment
    COMMUNITY VIEW: Helicopters add third dimension to property rights
    Wed., Feb. 18 | 09:00 AM
    Dear Loudoun family: find a good tax accountant
    Wed., Feb. 18 | 08:30 AM
    For retirees, problem is worse
    Wed., Feb. 18 | 08:00 AM
    1 comment
    OpEd: Budget season madness
    Wed., Feb. 11 | 10:00 AM
    3 comments
    A favorite place changes
    Wed., Feb. 11 | 09:45 AM
    5 comments
    COMMUNITY VIEW: Legalizing marijuana
    Wed., Feb. 11 | 09:00 AM
    2 comments
    Road closure impacts businesses
    Wed., Feb. 11 | 08:30 AM
    Selecting Loudoun judges should be an open process
    Wed., Feb. 11 | 08:00 AM
    COMMUNITY VIEW: Loudoun’s “legion of homeless” is growing
    Wed., Feb. 4 | 03:57 PM
    There’s never enough money to fund grandiose schemes of school leaders
    Wed., Feb. 4 | 03:56 PM
    Heliport is incompatible with western Loudoun
    Wed., Feb. 4 | 03:55 PM
    Despite support of community,  burden of hunger grows in Loudoun
    Wed., Feb. 4 | 03:53 PM
    Bill would benefit education
    Wed., Feb. 4 | 03:52 PM
    1 comment
    COMMUNITY VIEW: Conservation easements endangered
    Wed., Jan. 28 | 09:30 AM
    1 comment
    “The appalling silence of the good people.”
    Wed., Jan. 28 | 09:00 AM
    Democrats support needs-based school budget
    Wed., Jan. 28 | 08:30 AM
    2 comments
    Schools need a will and a way
    Wed., Jan. 28 | 08:00 AM
    1 comment
    COMMUNITY VIEW: Finding the right school for your child
    Wed., Jan. 21 | 09:15 AM
    Citizen to Congress: Quit your bickering
    Wed., Jan. 21 | 09:00 AM
    2 comments
    Parents have right to know school assessment data
    Wed., Jan. 21 | 08:30 AM
    2 comments
    Violence is a perversion of Islam
    Wed., Jan. 14 | 10:15 AM
    2 comments
    Shallow apology shows lack of responsibility
    Wed., Jan. 14 | 10:00 AM
    4 comments
    Get Email Updates
    Tuesdays:  
    Thursdays:

    StayConnected

    Follow Us
    on Twitter

    News | Sports

    Like Us
    on Facebook

    News & Sports

    Join Our
    Email List

    Sign up for
    weekly updates
    The Loudoun Times-Mirror

    is an interactive, digital replica
    of the printed newspaper.
    Open the e-edition now.

    Readers Choice Winter 2014

    February 2015 Leesburg Downtown

    2014 Holiday Leesburg Downtown

    2014 Loudoun Holiday Gift Guide

    Loudoun Business Journal - Fall 2014

    Loudoun Business Journal - Summer 2014

    Loudoun Business Journal - Spring 2014