Welcome to LoudounTimes.com
Loudoun Times-Mirror

Lawsuit hopes to make Virginia students who are not citizens eligible for in-state tuition

Legal Aid Justice Center files lawsuit in Arlington County on behalf of seven student plaintiffs

Rebeca Orellana Montano graduated from Washington-Lee High School in June with honors and a 4.3 grade point average and is currently studying Civil & Infrastructure Engineering at George Mason University as a freshman. But even though she has lived in Northern Virginia for 13 of her 18 years, she does not qualify for Virginia in-state tuition.

Montano was born in Bolivia and was brought to Virginia by her parents when she was 5 years old. “We came here on a visa that expired, and stayed,” she said. “That is what makes me ineligible for in-state tuition, and why I have to pay nearly three times as much as other students who I went to high school with.”

Under the Obama administration’s Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, Montano and about 7,000 other DACA students living in Virginia are authorized to work in the United States, obtain a social security number, a Virginia driver’s license, and they can renew their DACA status indefinitely. But when it comes to higher education, they pay an average of two to three times the in-state tuition rate if they choose to attend college in their home state. For Montano, that means a four-year degree from GMU will cost her family nearly $120,000. “I don’t know how we will do it,” she said.

On Dec. 17, The Falls Church-based Legal Aid Justice Center filed a lawsuit in Arlington County on behalf of seven student plaintiffs like Montano — although she is not a plaintiff — who are asking the court to overrule the State Council of Higher Education for Virginia’s interpretation of the law, and recognize that DACA recipients should be eligible for much cheaper in-state tuition rates — like other Virginia high school graduates.

The federal DACA program was announced in June of 2012 and grants temporary relief for students living in the country without legal permission who were brought to the U.S. as minors, avoided run-ins with the law and graduated from high school, but currently SCHEV classifies them as categorically ineligible for in-state tuition rates at Virginia’s public colleges and universities. For some, such as Giancarla Rojas Mendoza, 19 — who graduated from Falls Church High School in Fairfax County in June 2012 — that can mean that a school such as GMU can be completely out of reach.

“I graduated with a 3.4 GPA and worked hard,” she said. “Education is a tool to help you to build a better life. I was always taught that if you worked hard, studied and got good grades, you could go to college. I am not asking for money, I am only asking for the same opportunity as others, and to not be treated differently and in such a way that it could impact my entire life.”

Mendoza is one of the seven plaintiffs in the lawsuit.

According to the Legal Aid Justice Center, the suit is part of a broad, multi-pronged effort to extend eligibility for in-state tuition to Virginia residents who have been granted DACA status. On behalf of its clients, Legal Aid Justice Center will also be asking the incoming McAuliffe administration to take executive action.

“We’re just asking the court to take a look at existing Virginia law,” said Legal Aid Justice Center attorney Simon Sandoval-Moshenberg. “We think the court will agree that under existing law, these students should be eligible for in-state tuition benefits, just like their other Virginia classmates.”

Plaintiffs will also be asking lawmakers to take legislative action during the upcoming General Assembly session again this year.

“This case is about Virginia high school graduates wanting to continue their education here in Virginia,” said Tim Freilich, Legal Director of the Legal Aid Justice Center’s Immigrant Advocacy Program.

“Virginia should be helping these students realize their dreams, not putting unnecessary obstacles in their path.”

SCHEV spokesperson Kirsten Nelson declined comment on the suit, citing pending litigation.

.(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)


Hopefully the case will be thrown out and attorney fees will be awarded. If they have been here since kindergarten taxpayers have already invested $125,000.00 in their K through 12 education. Enough is enough.

“We came here on a visa that expired, and stayed,”

So why not deal with that situation first, then worry about in-state vs. out of state tuition?  Is America the only country where having or not having a valid visa is apparently not a problem?

“We’re just asking the court to take a look at existing Virginia law… We think the court will agree that under existing law, these students should be eligible for in-state tuition benefits, just like their other Virginia classmates.”

Yeah- look at the part of the law that addresses ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION and how you are here ILLEGALLY! Why the phuck should you get the same privileges that I get when I have been paying VA taxes for over 30 years? If you can prove you/your parents have paid your state and federal taxes then yes, get your in-state tuition. Otherwise, phuck off.

If Rebeca Orellana Montano put as much effort into filling out an application for Citizenship, she might actually have a better shot at receiving in-state tuition. Instead of demanding that benefits be granted to Non-Citizens.

Hopefully I.C.E. officers are reading this article and putting her and her parents name on a list of folks to be captured for being in the country Illegally.

Once again, people who did not follow the rules, are asking for special treatment.  A family stays illegally and then wants everything this country has to offer for the people who did follow the rules, makes no sense.  It’s akin to cutting to the front of the line.  How is that fair for those who have followed the rules and are still waiting their turn ?

Easy solution. Go back over her parents Federal and VA state taxes 13 years ago to last year. If the parents didn’t pay the appropriate income taxes(both state and federal)then she should not qualify for in-state tuition.

Post a comment

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.

Comments express only the views of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of this website or any associated person or entity. Any user who believes a message is objectionable can contact us at ltmeditor@loudountimes.com.

More News

The Loudoun Times-Mirror

is an interactive, digital replica
of the printed newspaper.
Click here for all e-editions.