Welcome to LoudounTimes.com
Loudoun Times-Mirror

Loudoun School Board refuses to offer supervisors a ‘cut list’

Loudoun County supervisors were none too pleased to receive a letter yesterday from School Board Chairman Eric Hornberger telling them the School Board will not respond to the supervisors' request for more-detailed information about the Loudoun County Public Schools adopted budget.

Hornberger's letter, which supervisors derided during a Wednesday night meeting, adds extra hostility between the two governing bodies three days before they're scheduled to meet to discuss the school system's fiscal 2015 budget.

The letter also questions whether the Board of Supervisors has the statutory authority to ask for “information about what programmatic needs and requirements could be fulfilled or not fulfilled within the funding provided to the schools under the county administrator's proposal” – verbiage lifted from a February request from Board of Supervisors Chairman Scott York (R-At Large) to the School Board.

In his ire-raising reply, Hornberger said the LCPS budget is what his board believes is “needed to move [LCPS] forward.”

“Requesting a 'cut list' implies that the budget duly proposed does not really reflect our true needs for our school division,” Hornberger's letter states. “Rather, that the School Board proposed budget represents funding levels in excess of our needs – which is not the case.”

Earlier this year the School Board adopted a $950 million budget, which leaves a nearly $40 million gap between the school system's budget and county appropriations within the county administrator's proposed spending plan.

In his letter, Hornberger continued, “Complying with your request could be misconstrued as tacit authorization of a line-item veto to the Board of Supervisors without our proposed budget, which is in conflict with the roles of the two bodies set forth in the Code of Virginia.”

“There is no requirement, nor precedent, that we cut our needs-based budget prior to the Board of Supervisors determination of the the funding level it is willing to appropriate to meet our request,” the School Board chairman noted. “While we understand your desire for us to do so to better enable you to meet your own budgetary goals, we feel it would be inappropriate for us to do so given our responsibility to represent the needs of the school system ...”

Appearing irritated, supervisors on Wednesday said they aren't interested in going through the LCPS budget line by line. Instead, Board of Supervisors members said they just want a greater understanding of the School Board's priorities.

Moreover, supervisors claimed they're not seeking a 'cut list.'

“Our word was prioritize. Their words are 'cut list,'” Supervisor Ralph Buona (R-Ashburn) said. “They have not prioritized. They only held four budget work sessions. One School Board member, who I'll keep anonymous, told me, 'we were too worn out from the redistricting process and looking for a new superintendent [than] to spend the time on the budget.'”

Buona and Supervisor Suzanne Volpe (R-Algonkian) said the Board of Supervisors, as the county's appropriating body, has the right to ask questions about how the money will be spent.

“I don't believe [School Board members] know their priorities,” Buona said, adding he believes there are “excuses” in the LCPS budget. “I hope they will govern … and governing doesn't mean hiding behind a fictitious constitutional excuse.”

County Attorney Jack Roberts agreed with his bosses, the supervisors, on the matter of Virginia law.

“There is explicit authority for you to ask for information that you deem advisable in the budget process from any board, commission, agency that gets money appropriated to it,” Roberts said in response to a question from Supervisor Matt Letourneau (R-Dulles).

Contact the writer at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address).


The why it should work is the BoS provides the School Board $XXX/millions and the School Board does whatever it wants with the money to provide a quality education to the students. If there is a problem in that quality, the “voters” will fix the problem when they vote on school board members.

The BoS has no standing to request details on how the School Board plans to do if they are short on funds and have to do some creative personnel shifting.

@ achmafooma….its actually 80% of the countys budget, and it has been that way for years.  when you get your property tax bill for your cars. look at the paper work, it has the break down where our tax dollars go.  80 cents of each dollar goes to schools!!!

The U.S. spends more on education per-capita than almost any other country in the world (http://mercatus.org/publication/k-12-spending-student-oecd).

Even inflation-adjusted, we’re spending four times more on schools (per-student) than we did in 1960 (http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=66).

Well over 50% of the county budget goes to the schools. That’s more than public safety, libraries, parks, transportation, and all other county services COMBINED.

And the school board thinks that nobody has the right to question this level of spending? The school board thinks the BOS should just write a check for the requested amount and keep quiet? What hubris!

This is partially thanks to Charles Beard’s philosophy of economic determinism, which states that economics is the SOLE MOTIVATING FACTOR of our decisions… <sigh> if only we could take a look at the root issues itself instead of bickering over the money. Sure money does help, but if you pull back the blanket of money issues, you’ll find much more problems.

Satchmo…your call for maturity and civility will not stand!(note the sarcasm please).  It’s an age old issue with these 2 groups.  Thoughtful consideration and dialogue being replaced by egos and showmanship.  Every term, there is just a little more erosion to the fabric of cooperative spirit that should exist between the BOS and the School Board.  Meanwhile we are left to bear the brunt of these “2 kids arguing in the backseat.”

Note to Supervisors:

School Board members are elected just as you are.  Nothing makes a School Board member subservient to a Supervisor and visa-a-versa.  You are equals.  Figure this thing out.  Somewhere in the middle is the correct answer.  Start by being realistic, balance that with public opinion and then work together.  Anything else sounds like a bunch of whinny babies.

Post a comment

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.

Comments express only the views of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of this website or any associated person or entity. Any user who believes a message is objectionable can contact us at ltmeditor@loudountimes.com.

More News

The Loudoun Times-Mirror

is an interactive, digital replica
of the printed newspaper.
Click here for all e-editions.